Australia and US spied on Indonesia during UN summit — report
November 03, 2013 11:20
Australia and the US worked side by side on a large-scale joint surveillance operation on Indonesia, during the 2007 UN climate change conference in Bali, a new report from the NSA leaker, Edward Snowden, has revealed.
In 2007, Australia's newly elected prime minister, Kevin Rudd, attended the summit in Bali at the personal invitation of the Indonesian President.
According to the document cited by the Guardian newspaper's Australian edition, the US and Australia's intelligence agencies were looking to collect the phone numbers of Indonesian security officials.
It was not a particularly successful operation, though, the Guardian noted, with the only practical outcome the National Security Agency (NSA) and the Defence Signals Directorate (DSD) achieved was the mobile phone number of Bali’s chief of police.
According to an account of the mission, included in a weekly report from the NSA base in Australia, at Pine Gap, dated January 2008:
"The goal of the development effort was to gain a solid understanding of the network structure should collection be required in the event of an emergency."
Compromise of mobile for Bali chief of police
At the end of the operation the NSA wrapped up:
“Highlights include the compromise of the mobile phone number for Bali’s chief of police.
“Site efforts revealed previously unknown Indonesian communications networks and postured us to increase collection in the event of a crisis.”
Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

Australia and US spied on Indonesia during UN summit.

Picture: AFP/Bay Ismoyo
Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono
The embarrassing revelation has heated up tensions between Australia and Indonesia.
Indonesia has called in the Australian ambassador in Jakarta for an explanation.
The Indonesian foreign minister said it was "not cricket" for Australia to spy on the region along with the US.
Earlier reports revealed by Snowden have showed that the US has been busy monitoring communication activities of up to 35 world leaders.
These include German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, and Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff.
Communications of hundreds of millions of people across the world were also monitored, the leaked documents revealed, including British, French, Spanish and American citizens.
Indonesian foreign minister Marty Natalegawa:
“If Australia was itself subjected to such an activity do you consider it as being a friendly act or not?
We are deeply concerned and it's something we cannot accept.
I'm not sure what is the right term in Australian terminology.
I guess it's not cricket.”
Relations between the two sides became aggravated after it was reported that Australian diplomatic missions in Asia were allegedly used to intercept phone calls and data.
A report based on a secret NSA document and published this week in Der Spiegel and the Sydney Morning Herald, has named a number of cities in which Asian embassies have been used for electronic surveillance by a group of intelligence partners known as the 'Five Eyes' — the US, the UK, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand — all of whom are bound by a written intelligence-sharing agreement.
The embassies allegedly involved in the spying spree are Jakarta, Bangkok, Beijing, Hanoi, Kuala Lumpur, and Malaysia, among others.
We all operate in accordance with the law
Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott refused to comment on the specifics of the state's intelligence activities, but said that "the thing about every Australian governmental agency is that we all operate in accordance with the law."
"Now, as for the precise workings of our intelligence organizations, it's been a long-standing practice not to comment on them," he told reporters.
Copyright © Autonomous Nonprofit Organization
"TV-Novosti" 2005–2013. All rights reserved.
NSA shares raw intelligence including American data with Israel.

Israel is receiving raw unminimized intelligence data from the NSA.

Anything the agency has swept up - including data on American citizens - is being handed over to Israel's intelligence, restriction-free.

Image: Reuters/Nigel Roddis
Click on image for TechDirt.com article
Files make clear British GCHQ played leading role advising European counterparts how to
work around national laws
intended to restrict surveillance power of intelligence agencies
GCHQ and European spy agencies worked together on mass surveillance
Julian Borger
Friday 1 November 2013
The German, French, Spanish and Swedish intelligence services have all developed methods of mass surveillance of internet and phone traffic over the past five years in close partnership with Britain's GCHQ eavesdropping agency.
The bulk monitoring is carried out through direct taps into fibre optic cables and the development of covert relationships with telecommunications companies.
A loose but growing eavesdropping alliance has allowed intelligence agencies from one country to cultivate ties with corporations from another to facilitate the trawling of the web, according to GCHQ documents leaked by the former US intelligence contractor
Edward Snowden.
GCHQ Britain Government Communications Headquarters for spying knowing everything about everyone in Cheltenham UK

Photo: Reuters
GCHQ Britain Government Headquarters for knowing everything about everyone in Cheltenham UK
Photo: Reuters
image insterted by TheWE.cc
The files also make clear that GCHQ played a leading role in advising its European counterparts how to work around national laws intended to restrict the surveillance power of intelligence agencies.
The German, French and Spanish governments have reacted angrily to reports based on
National Security Agency (NSA) files leaked by Snowden since June, revealing the interception of communications by tens of millions of their citizens each month.
US intelligence officials have insisted the mass monitoring was
carried out by the security agencies in the countries involved and shared with the US.
Democratic societies cannot flourish in veil of secrecy
The US director of national intelligence, James Clapper, suggested to Congress on Tuesday that European governments' professed outrage at the reports was at least partly hypocritical.
"Some of this reminds me of the classic movie Casablanca: 'My God, there's gambling going on here,' " he said.
Sweden, which passed a law in 2008 allowing its intelligence agency to monitor cross-border email and phone communications without a court order, has been relatively muted in its response.
The German government, however, has expressed disbelief and fury at the revelations from the Snowden documents, including the fact that the NSA monitored Angela Merkel's mobile phone calls.
After the Guardian revealed the existence of
GCHQ's Tempora programme, in which the electronic intelligence agency tapped directly into the transatlantic fibre optic cables to carry out bulk surveillance, the German justice minister, Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger, said it sounded "like a Hollywood nightmare", and warned the UK government that free and democratic societies could not flourish when states shielded their actions in "a veil of secrecy".
GCHQ term for fibre optic cables
However, in a country-by-country survey of its European partners, GCHQ officials expressed admiration for the technical capabilities of German intelligence to do the same thing.
GCHQ assisting German Swedish French Spanish Dutch governments spying on everyone.

Government intrusion into everyone's life

Photo: Ulrich Baumgarten/Getty Images
GCHQ assisting German Swedish French Spanish Dutch
government intrusion into everyone's life
Image: Ulrich Baumgarten/Getty Images
The survey in 2008, when Tempora was being tested, said the Federal Intelligence Service (BND), had "huge technological potential and good access to the heart of the internet — they are already seeing some bearers running at 40Gbps and 100Gbps".
Bearers is the GCHQ term for the fibre optic cables, and gigabits per second (Gbps) measures the speed at which data runs through them. Four years after that report, GCHQ was still only able to monitor 10 Gbps cables, but looked forward to tap new 100 Gbps bearers eventually.
Hence the admiration for the BND.
The document also makes clear that British intelligence agencies were helping their German counterparts change or bypass laws that restricted their ability to use their advanced surveillance technology.
"We have been assisting the BND (along with SIS [Secret Intelligence Service] and Security Service) in making the case for reform or reinterpretation of the very restrictive interception legislation in Germany," it says.
GCHQ host major conference on how to spy
The country-by-country survey, which in places reads somewhat like a school report, also hands out high marks to the GCHQ's French partner, the General Directorate for External Security (DGSE).
But in this case it is suggested that the DGSE's comparative advantage is its relationship with an unnamed telecommunications company, a relationship GCHQ hoped to leverage for its own operations.
"DGSE are a highly motivated, technically competent partner, who have shown great willingness to engage on IP [internet protocol] issues, and to work with GCHQ on a "cooperate and share" basis."
Noting that the Cheltenham-based electronic intelligence agency had trained DGSE technicians on "multi-disciplinary internet operations", the document says: "We have made contact with the DGSE's main industry partner, who has some innovative approaches to some internet challenges, raising the potential for GCHQ to make use of this company in the protocol development arena."
GCHQ British Government disregard for law of the people of Britain and of most of Europe.

GCHQ's outpost at Bude, close to where trans-Atlantic fibre-optic cables come ashore in Cornwall, southwest England 

Photo: Reuters
GCHQ outpost at Bude close to where trans-Atlantic fibre-optic cables come ashore in Cornwall England
British Government disregard for law of the people of Britain and of most of Europe
Photo: Reuters/Kieran Doherty
image insterted by TheWE.cc
GCHQ went on to host a major conference with its French partner on joint internet-monitoring initiatives in March 2009 and four months later reported on shared efforts on what had become by then GCHQ's biggest challenge – continuing to carry out bulk surveillance, despite the spread of commercial online encryption, by breaking that encryption.
"Very friendly crypt meeting with DGSE in July," British officials reported.
The French were "clearly very keen to provide presentations on their work which included cipher detection in high-speed bearers.
"[GCHQ's] challenge is to ensure that we have enough UK capability to support a longer term crypt relationship."
Corporate relations are among most strictly guarded secrets in intelligence community
In the case of the Spanish intelligence agency, the National Intelligence Centre (CNI), the key to mass internet surveillance, at least back in 2008, was the Spaniards' ties to a British telecommunications company (again unnamed. Corporate relations are among the most strictly guarded secrets in the intelligence community).
That was giving them "fresh opportunities and uncovering some surprising results.
The report said:
"GCHQ has not yet engaged with CNI formally on IP exploitation, but the CNI have been making great strides through their relationship with a UK commercial partner.
GCHQ and the commercial partner have been able to coordinate their approach.
The commercial partner has provided the CNI some equipment whilst keeping us informed, enabling us to invite the CNI across for IP-focused discussions this autumn,"
The report concluded that GCHQ
"have found a very capable counterpart in CNI, particularly in the field of Covert Internet Ops".
GCHQ delighted at Swedish parliament
GCHQ was clearly delighted in 2008 when the Swedish parliament passed a bitterly contested law allowing the country's National Defence Radio Establishment (FRA) to conduct Tempora-like operations on fibre optic cables.
The British agency also claimed some credit for the success.
"FRA have obtained a … probe to use as a test-bed and we expect them to make rapid progress in IP exploitation following the law change," the country assessment said.
"GCHQ has already provided a lot of advice and guidance on these issues and we are standing by to assist the FRA further once they have developed a plan for taking the work forwards."
The following year, GCHQ held a conference with its Swedish counterpart "for discussions on the implications of the new legislation being rolled out" and hailed as "a success in Sweden" the news that FRA "have finally found a pragmatic solution to enable release of intelligence to SAEPO [the internal Swedish security service.]"
GCHQ on hand to deal with legal constraints
GCHQ also maintains strong relations with the two main Dutch intelligence agencies, the external MIVD and the internal security service, the AIVD.
"Both agencies are small, by UK standards, but are technically competent and highly motivated," British officials reported.
Once again, GCHQ was on hand in 2008 for help in dealing with legal constraints.
"The AIVD have just completed a review of how they intend to tackle the challenges posed by the internet — GCHQ has provided input and advice to this report," the country assessment said.
"The Dutch have some legislative issues that they need to work through before their legal environment would allow them to operate in the way that GCHQ does.
We are providing legal advice on how we have tackled some of these issues to Dutch lawyers."
GCHQ Europe's intelligence hub
In the score-card of European allies, it appears to be the Italians who come off the worse.
GCHQ expresses frustration with the internal friction between Italian agencies and the legal limits on their activities.
"GCHQ has had some CT [counter-terrorism] and internet-focused discussions with both the foreign intelligence agency (AISE) and the security service (AISI), but has found the Italian intelligence community to be fractured and unable/unwilling to cooperate with one another," the report said.
A follow-up bulletin six months later noted that GCHQ was "awaiting a response from AISI on a recent proposal for cooperation — the Italians had seemed keen, but legal obstacles may have been hindering their ability to commit."
It is clear from the Snowden documents that GCHQ has become Europe's intelligence hub in the internet age, and not just because of its success in creating a legally permissive environment for its operations.
Britain's location as the European gateway for many transatlantic cables, and its privileged relationship with the NSA has made GCHQ an essential partner for European agencies.
The documents show British officials frequently lobbying the NSA on sharing of data with the Europeans and haggling over its security classification so it can be more widely disseminated.
In the intelligence world, far more than it managed in diplomacy, Britain has made itself an indispensable bridge between America and Europe's spies.
Subheadings by TheWE.cc
© 2013 Guardian Newspapers Limited or its affiliated companies.  All rights reserved.
NSA GCHQ Spying centers which provides communications and intelligence support services to the United Kingdom and the U.S. and intrusion of US and UK government into your most intimate aspects of life.

Image: AFP/Josep Lago
NSA GCHQ US UK spying into most intimate aspects of life
AFP/Josep Lago
Spying center RAF Menwith Hill base intrusion of US UK governments into your most intimate aspects of life.

Spying center which provides communications and intelligence support services to the United Kingdom and the U.S. is pictured near Harrogate, northern England.

Image: Reuters/Nigel Roddis
Spying center RAF Menwith Hill base intrusion of US UK governments
Reuters/Nigel Roddis
NSA GCHQ Spying centers which provides communications and intelligence support services to the United Kingdom and the U.S. and intrusion of US and UK government into your most intimate aspects of life.

Image: AFP/Lluis Gene
NSA GCHQ US UK spying
AFP/Lluis Gene
Unspeakable grief and horror
                        ...and the continues...
— 2018
— 2017
— 2016
— 2015
— 2014
— 2013
— 2012
— 2011
— 2010
— 2009
— 2008
— 2007
— 2006
— 2005
— 2004
— 2003
Circus of Torture   2003 — now
For Kewe's spiritual and metaphysical pages — click here
 Kewe ArchivesNews you might have missedTheWE.cc index pageThe Planet