For archive purposes, this article is being stored on TheWE.cc website.
The purpose is to advance understandings of environmental, political,
human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues.

 
 
Wednesday, 9 June, 2004
Critics question Reagan legacy
By Richard Allen Greene
BBC News Online

Ronald Reagan in 1992
Nothing stuck to the "Teflon President", opponents said
As tens of thousands of Americans file past the casket of Ronald Reagan, some observers are quietly — and not so quietly — beginning to question the accolades heaped on the late president since his death.

Many obituaries have highlighted his sunny charm and good humour, while others have credited him with helping to end the Cold War, restore America's confidence in itself and "get government off people's back", as he himself would have put it.

But critics point out that there was another side to his presidency — record budget deficits, economic pressure on the middle class, human rights abuses in Central America, and the Iran-Contra scandal.

Correctives are being issued even to the claim that he was the most popular president in modern history.

Less popular than successors

Gallup poll data suggest that he was roughly as popular as Bill Clinton over time — with President Clinton running slightly higher approval ratings than Reagan during the second half of each man's presidency.
Past presidents look a lot better when compared to the present
Mark Weisbrot,
Economist

And neither ever reached the 90% approval ratings that both George W Bush and his father achieved briefly early in their terms.

Economist Mark Weisbrot says the adulation in the wake of Reagan's death is natural.

"Past presidents look a lot better when compared to the present," he told BBC News Online.

Even Richard Nixon — forced to resign in disgrace — was remembered as a great statesman when he died, rather than as the architect of Watergate, said Mr Weisbrot, of the liberal Center for Economic and Policy Research.

But he is unreserved in his own evaluation of Reagan, dismissing his economic policies as "mostly a failure" and accusing him of backing governments that engaged in systematic rape and torture.

Reagan promoted an economic theory known as "supply-side economics" — which George Bush senior famously derided as "voodoo economics" when running against Reagan for the Republican presidential nomination in 1980.

The theory held that tax cuts for the rich would lead them to save and invest money, leading to increased productivity and lower unemployment.

Weak economy

"None of this happened," Mr Weisbrot said. "If you look at the 1980s, it was the worst decade of post-World War II growth.

"The median wage was flat, and there was a massive redistribution of income, with wealth going to the top one or two percent of the population," he said.
He was like everybody's grandfather — nobody would believe that he would cut student aid or not be for the environment
Patricia Schroeder,
Former Congresswoman



He was scathing over the Reagan administration's backing for anti-Communist Guatemalan strongman Efrain Rios Montt, who led the Central American country during some of the worst human rights abuses of its 36-year-long civil war.

"Congress required him to certify that [Guatemala] was improving human rights, which he did. Reagan was praising Rios Montt when there were systematic rapes and tortures going on," he said.

Other critics have pointed out that — perhaps more mundanely — Reagan's fiscal rhetoric rarely matched his actions.

Former Congresswoman Patricia Schroeder still laughs when recalling budget battles with the Reagan White House.

"This is a person who said he believed in balanced budgets but ran the biggest deficit in history," she said.

"He never produced a balanced budget," the self-described liberal Democrat told BBC News Online.

Reagan promised to reduce the size of government — but government spending increased by 25%, adjusted for inflation, on his watch, Timothy Noah wrote in the online journal Slate.

And the number of civilian government employees increased slightly, he added.

"Fittingly, the Ronald Reagan Building... today houses 5,000 employees and is the largest government building in Washington," he wrote.

'Teflon President'

But even at the time the public rarely blamed him for failing to live up to his words — leading Mrs Schroeder to coin the phrase "Teflon President" to describe him.

"No one could believe that he could do anything wrong," she said. "He was like everybody's grandfather — nobody would believe that he would cut student aid or not be for the environment."
Oliver North testifies over the Iran-contra scandal
North said he thought Reagan knew about the Iran-Contra affair

She said Reagan's staff managed to deflect blame from the president.

"The White House was very managed. If anything went wrong, they would blame the staff, not him."

The policy reached its apotheosis in the scandal that became known as the Iran-Contra affair.

Banned by Congress from supporting anti-Communist fighters in Nicaragua, Reagan's National Security Council (NSC) backed them secretly — with money raised by selling arms to Iran in violation of a separate US embargo.

When word of the arrangement leaked out, NSC chair John Poindexter resigned; the man who directed the operation, Lt Col Oliver North, was fired.

Eleven administration officials were convicted on criminal charges over the affair.
Impeaching Reagan should certainly have been considered
Lawrence Walsh,
Iran-Contra special prosecutor



Oliver North claimed Reagan and then Vice-President George Bush senior knew about the arrangements, but they denied it and no evidence was ever found to disprove their claims.

A special prosecutor's report said that Reagan and Vice-President Bush had some knowledge of either the arrangement or the cover-up.

The arms sales to Iran "were carried out with the knowledge of, among others, President Ronald Reagan" and his vice-president, prosecutor Lawrence Walsh concluded.

The Reagan administration "wilfully withheld... large volumes of highly relevant, contemporaneously created documents", he added.

He said impeaching Reagan "certainly should have been considered", the Washington Post reported.

But Mr Walsh's report was not completed until 1994 — the year that Reagan announced that he had Alzheimer's disease and withdrew from public life.

After her years of fighting the Reagan administration, Mrs Schroeder is now philosophical about the battles of the 1980s.

"History has got to be neutral," she said. "In 30 or 40 years we will look back and see what actually happened."


RONALD REAGAN 1911 - 2004

POLITICAL LEGACY

Ronald ReaganMilitary debt
Much of the current conventional firepower of the US is a legacy of the Reagan years.

LIFE, LOVE AND MOVIES

Nancy and Ronald Reagan on his 89th birthdayA life in pictures
Images from the life of the shoe salesman's son who became film star and president.

WATCH/LISTEN
Ronald Reagan


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites




www.Democracynow.org


Transcript of interview with journalist Alan Friedman, author of Spider's Web: The Secret History of How the White House Illegally Armed Iraq

The interview discusses how Reagan normalized U.S. relations with Iraq and sold chemical weapons to Saddam Hussein.


ALAN FRIEDMAN: What we're looking at is we need to put this into its historic context so that I'd like to do for your listeners is talk about how Ronald Reagan and George Herbert Walker Bush, and James Baker who was Secretary of State, and Robert Gates, who was the C.I.A. Director in the 1980's, how they met what was called a tilt policy in favor of Iraq and against Iran in the 1980's and developed what they thought was strategic reasons were for the United States to be doing that.

Then the sad story of how it got out of control, how Vice President Bush was deeply personally involved in illegal arms transfers to Saddam Hussein in the late 1980's that shouldn't have happened, and how the Bush Administration, that's Bush one, then proceeded with the help of Boyden Gray as White House general counsel and others to cover up a scandal that in my judgment was significantly larger than Watergate.

Lets put it into historical context.

In the 1980's, the Reagan White House wasn't just busy defeating the so-called evil empire of the Soviet Union and out spending and bankrupting the Soviets, they were also engaged in a Middle East Policy in Iraq and Iran, that was aimed at obviously trying to defeat and neutralize the Islamic fundamentalists of Iran which were Americas perceived enemy at the time.

To defeat Iran, we will fortify Saddam, he may be a killer. He may be a butcher, but he's our guy. We will keep him to keep a balance of power between Iran and Iraq.

What that meant in order to get around U.S. law — which says that you cannot conduct illegal secret covert operations without Presidential directive, approve as and disclosure to the Senate oversight committees — rogue operations very similar to the Iran contra operation and indeed in many cases involving the same C.I.A. front companies in Virginia, the same shippers from Florida, and Louisiana, the same people who worked with Ollie North on the Iran-contra scandal were also involved in getting arms to Iraq in the 1980's.

They did this in the following way.

They let a small Atlanta, Georgia, branch of an Italian bank receive taxpayers' money in the form of U.S. Department of Agriculture credits that the United States provided for Iraq totaling $5 billion — b for boy — dollars that went to Saddam Hussein with the knowledge of the C.I.A. and the White House, which turned a blind eye, because they thought they had to find a way to help Iraq against Iran.

Of now, that Iraq-Iran war in part thanks to U.S. assistance for Saddam Hussein went years longer than this should have done, and resulted in 1 million, men, women and children dying.

1 million people died in the Iran-Iraq war and Reagan and Bush probably have blood on their hands, because if they hadn't sent the military equipment to Iraq, fewer people would have died.

When the war between Iran and Iraq ended, and we were already in 1988, 1989, 1990, the Bush administration, the same policies continued.

The C.I.A. was reinforced, and this stuff kept going.

In my investigations, and those I conduct with Ted Koppel of ABC "Nightline," — and Bill Safire of the "New York Times" was active in exposing as well — we not only discovered that illegal set of shipments [were being sent] to Saddam Hussein with the blessing of the Bush white house, but we covered that the something got out of cool — control, and we kept going.

We're talking about elements that go well beyond helicopters and include the building blocks of nuclear weapons, weapons of mass destruction.

Inertial navigation systems and cluster bombs from Lancaster, Pennsylvania, that found their way to Saddam Hussein thanks to George Herbert Walker Bush and his C.I.A. and their shipments using taxpayer money.

Strong words, all of it documented, all of it little focused upon as America pays tribute to Ronald Reagan's death and makes him into a hero when indeed, his and Bush's policies in my judgment resulted in major loss of life and major strategic errors by the United States that they sought to cover up later on.

AMY GOODMAN: As we look at the 1980's, Donald Rumsfeld — as Reagan envoy reported by my colleague, Jeremy Skahill at Democracy Now! in his piece, "The Saddam and Rumsfeld's Closet" — in 1983 and 1948 goes to Iraq, meets with Saddam Hussein at the time when the U.N. and State Department reports had come out saying that Saddam Hussein had used gas.

He wasn't there to condemn Saddam Hussein for this, but to normalize relations. Can talk about -

ALAN FRIEDMAN: Can I interrupt you and tell you what Donald Rumsfeld did in Baghdad?

Donald Rumsfeld went to Baghdad, was met by Saddam Hussein at the airport.

That's right.

Donald Rumsfeld.

With a big Rumsfeld grin on his face said, "I'm really glad to be here in Baghdad with my good friend, Saddam Hussein," and proceeded to carry messages back and forth for the Reagan administration of active military and economic support for Saddam Hussein.

I think it's important you don't need to be a conspiracy theorist of course because there are people who make up stories.

You just need to look at the facts to understand that the same Rumsfeld and the same Bush advisers, the coterie of C.I.A. and military types who have been around the family of the father and are now in the administration of the son, are the same people who built up Saddam Hussein as our guy, and turned a blind eye at his atrocities, and slapped him on the back, literally, physically, Rumsfeld in his jovial way, slapped Saddam on Iraq Saddam and said, great to do business with Iraq, our friend.

And the same people used the same funds to support Osama bin Laden in the late 1970's and early 1980's in Afghanistan to fight the Soviet Union.

We create these monsters and then when's not convenient we cover them up.

The press is not what it used to be and has forgotten how to investigate criminal acts by the White House.

That's where we are today.

AMY GOODMAN: Rumsfeld brought from Saddam Hussein golden cowboy spurs and pistols.

ALAN FRIEDMAN: He brought presents like those.

AMY GOODMAN: I was wondering if the pistol that now George W. Bush shows to friends just off the Oval office that soldiers had given to him that they had gotten from Saddam Hussein's, one of his offices or palaces is perhaps the one that Reagan gave to them?

ALAN FRIEDMAN: I think that's unlikely.

I think it's a different pistol.

But the real bottom line is that if you want to go to the depths of his involvement, let me mention a couple of things. Alexander Hague, and Bobby Ray Inman, two names from the 90's, who are associated with the Reagan era.

Bobby Ray Inman did not become Secretary of Defense under Reagan and Bush.

Safire and Ted Koppel and I exposed the fact that Bobby Ray Inman of Defense Intelligence had been literal paid by one of the companies that shipped cluster bombs to Iraq and he couldn't get out of that allegation because it was documented and the senate failed to confirm him at the time.

It was a cowboy mentality at the time.

I think it unfortunately created the framework and set the stage for the tragedy we have seen in recent days, weeks and months.

AMY GOODMAN: Alan Friedman, I want to thank you very much for being with us.

Alan Friedman is the author of "Spider's Web. The Secret History of How the White House Allegedly Armed Iraq" and we are posting on our website, the hour interview that we did with Alan Friedman in the last year.



More on Ronald Reagan:   including journalist Alan Friedman and other interviews at www.Democracynow.org

To find audio and video interviews, in search, type Reagan 









TheWE.cc